Report re 'GMC and Dr Barton Report on Gladys Richards (Patient E)' prepared by Professor Gary A Ford (Consultant Physician)
- 21 Apr 2009
- Andrew Pate
- Document ID: APA000014
Refers to: Medicine and Dr Barton. Associated with: APA000001.
102 results found
Refers to: Medicine and Dr Barton. Associated with: APA000001.
Email exchange includes Rachel Cooper. Professor Forrest (toxicologist).
Before: Mr Anthony Bradley (Coroner for North Hampshire, Assistant Deputy Coroner for South East Hampshire). Attendees: Mr Alan Jenkins QC (on behalf of Dr Jane Barton), Mr James Townsend (Counsel, RCN, on behalf of a number of nurse witnesses), Ms Briony Ballard (Counsel, on behalf of the acute trust and the PCT), Mr Tom Leeper (Counsel, Blake Lapthorn, on behalf of the families) and Patrick Sadd (Counsel, on behalf of the Wilson family).
Chairman: Mr Andrew Reid. Panel Members: Ms Joy Julien, Mrs Pamela Mansell, Mr William Payne and Dr Roger Smith. Legal Assessor: Mr Francis Chamberlain. Other attendees: Mr Tom Kark (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Ben Fitzgerald (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Timothy Langdale QC (Medical Defence Union) and Mr Alan Jenkins (Medical Defence Union). Refers to: Mr Daniel Redfern (Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon), Dr Richard Reid, Dr Tandy, Professor Ford, Enid Spurgin, Royal Preston Hospital, Oriel College (Oxford), St Bartholomew's Hospital Medical College in London, Royal College of Surgeons for Orthopaedics, St Mary's Hospital, Hammersmith and Charing Cross Hospitals, Hampshire Police, Enid Spurgin, Royal Haslar Hospital, Medicine, x-rays, Royal College of Physicians, East Hampshire Primary Care Trust, Gosport Primary Care Trust, Queen Alexandra Hospital, BNF, Sheila Gregory, Elsie Devine, Geoffrey Packman, Gladys Richards, Dryad Ward, Daedalus Ward, Surgeon Commander Scott, Sister Rankin, Dr Tandy, Dr Ravindrane, Dr Chatterjee, Dr Luznat [Lusznat?], Mr Millett and Dr Turner. Associated with: CPS000066 - CPS000078.
Chairman: Mr Andrew Reid. Panel Members: Ms Joy Julien, Mrs Pamela Mansell, Mr William Payne and Dr Roger Smith. Legal Assessor: Mr Francis Chamberlain. Other attendees: Mr Tom Kark (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Ben Fitzgerald (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Timothy Langdale QC (Medical Defence Union) and Mr Alan Jenkins (Medical Defence Union). Refers to: Professor Gary Ashley Ford, Lola Babatunde, Mrs Lake, Royal College of Physicians, Freeman Hospital, Walkergate Hospital, Dr Reid, British National Formulary, Medicine, Dr X, NICE, British Hypertension Society Guideline on Hypertension, Wessex Protocols, 'Prescribing for the Elderly', 'Good Medical Practice', Mr Pittock, Mulberry Ward, Dr Tandy, Nurse Ring, Nurse Douglas, Sister Hamblin and 'a specific charge relating to the prescription on the 18 January' (addition of Nozinan to drugs already prescribed). Associated with: CPS000089 - CPS00099.
Chairman: Mr Andrew Reid. Panel Members: Ms Joy Julien, Mrs Pamela Mansell, Mr William Payne and Dr Roger Smith. Legal Assessor: Mr Francis Chamberlain. Other attendees: Mr Tom Kark (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Ben Fitzgerald (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Timothy Langdale QC (Medical Defence Union) and Mr Alan Jenkins (Medical Defence Union). Refers to: Professor Gary Ashley Ford, Elsie Lavender, Royal Hospital Haslar, Dr Tandy, Daedalus Ward, Charles Ward, Dryad Ward, Dr Lord, BNF, Wessex protocol, Mrs Eva Page, Alice Wilkie, QAH, Addenbrookes, Dr Peters, Gladys Richards, Surgeon Commander Malcolm Pott, Medicine, Ruby Lake, Nurse Hallman, Miss K, Mr Cunningham, Dolphin Day Hospital, Dr Banks, Mr Stewart-Farthing and Sister Hamblin. Associated with: CPS000089 - CPS00099.
Chairman: Mr Andrew Reid. Panel Members: Ms Joy Julien, Mrs Pamela Mansell, Mr William Payne and Dr Roger Smith. Legal Assessor: Mr Francis Chamberlain. Other attendees: Mr Tom Kark (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Ben Fitzgerald (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Timothy Langdale QC (Medical Defence Union) and Mr Alan Jenkins (Medical Defence Union). Refers to: Professor Gary Ashley Ford, Dr Lord, Alice Wilkie, Daedalus, Dr Peters, Addenbrooke, Philip Beed, Marilyn Jackson, Gladys Richards, Dr Reid, Haslar, Ruby Lake, Dryad Ward, Mr Cunningham, Dolphin Day Hospital, Thalassa Nursing Home, Mulberry Ward, Mr Farthing, Liverpool Care Pathway, British National Formulary, Palliative Care Handbook, Medicine, Dr Birla, Dr Ravindrane, Dr Knapman, Dr X, Enid Spurgin, Mr Wilson, Dr Woods, Dr Dowse, Mr Mick Backman, Dr Tandy, Dr Ravi, Nurse Hamblin, Elsie Devine, Queen Alexandra Hospital (QAH), Dr Stevens, Dr Lusznat and Dr Beasley. Associated with: CPS000100 - CPS000112.
Chairman: Mr Andrew Reid. Panel Members: Ms Joy Julien, Mrs Pamela Mansell, Mr William Payne and Dr Roger Smith. Legal Assessor: Mr Francis Chamberlain. Other attendees: Mr Tom Kark (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Ben Fitzgerald (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Timothy Langdale QC (Medical Defence Union) and Mr Alan Jenkins (Medical Defence Union). Refers to: Professor Gary Ashley Ford, Richard Oliver Samuel, Dr Logan, Dr Ravindrane, Medicine, J A Wilson, Palliative Care Handbook, Miss Alice Wilkie, Philip Beed, Arthur Cunningham, Mrs Jean Stevens, Daedalus Ward, Dr Reid, Portsmouth Healthcare Trust memorandum (dated 27 October 1999), Chief Executive, NHS, Hampshire Primary Care Trust, Strategic Health Authority, Mrs Gladys Richards, Redclyffe Annexe, Dryad Ward, Daedalus Ward, Sultan Ward, Royal Hospital Haslar, Portsmouth District Health Authority, Portsmouth HealthCare NHS Trust, Hampshire FPC and Dr Grunstein (Consultant Physician in Elderly Services, St Mary's). Associated with: CPS000100 - CPS000112.
Chairman: Mr Andrew Reid. Panel Members: Ms Joy Julien, Mrs Pamela Mansell, Mr William Payne and Dr Roger Smith. Legal Assessor: Mr Francis Chamberlain. Other attendees: Mr Tom Kark (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Ben Fitzgerald (Field Fisher Waterhouse), Mr Timothy Langdale QC (Medical Defence Union) and Mr Alan Jenkins (Medical Defence Union). Testimony given by Professor Karol Sikora. Refers to: Hammersmith Hospital, Cancer Partners UK, NHS, Cambridge University, Middlesex Hospital, Royal College of Radiologists, College of Physicians, Imperial College School of Medicine, Scientific Advisory Board of Source BioScience Plc, University of Buckingham, Cambridge Addenbrooke's Hospital, St Bartholomew's, MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge, Stanford University, Ludwig Institute, Help Hammer Cancer appeal, World Health Organisation, Pharmacia Corporation, UK Health Department's Expert Advisory Group on cancer, Committee on Safety of Medicines, Fitness to Practise Panel hearing, Commission for Health Improvement (CHI), Dr Barton, Gosport War Memorial Hospital, Dr Lord, Dr Tandy, Dr Reid, Professor Ford, Palliative Care Handbook, Wessex Procedure, WHO analgesic ladder, St Christopher's Hospice, Medicine, Eva Page, NHS, Liverpool Care Pathway, Sister Joines, Queen Alexandra Hospital, 'Good Medical Practice', BNF, Dr Wilkie, Dr Grunstein, Campbell case, Giffin, Tubritt [Tubbritt?] and Shirley Hallman. Associated with: CPS000126 - CPS000133.
Refers to: Depression, parkinsonis, Good Medical practice (GMC 2001), General Medical Council, Medicine, Curriculum Vitae of David Andrew Black, medical records, 'Operation Rochester Briefing Document Criminal Investigation Summary', 'Hampshire Constabulary Operation Rochester Guidance for Medical Experts', 'Commission for Health Improvement Investigation Report on Portsmouth Health Care NHS Trust at Gosport War Memorial Hospital (July 2002)', 'Palliative Care Handbook Guidelines on Clinical Management, Third Edition, Salisbury Palliative Care Services (1995); Also referred to as the 'Wessex Protocols.'', cellulitis, Medicine, Gosport War Memorial Elderly Mental Health beds, Dr Banks, Dryad Ward, Dr Lord (Consultant Geriatrician), hypoproteinaemia, nursing cardex records, Dr Barton, Dr Briggs, Staff Nurse Martin, British National Forumlary, Gosport War Memorial Hospital, drug chart, 'Palliative Care, Welsh J, Fallon M, Keelet PW, Brocklehurst Text Book of Geriatric Medicine, 6th edition, 2003, Chapter 23 pages 257-270', 'Wilson J A et al, Palliative Medicine 1987:149-153', 'Higginson I J and Constantini M Accuracy of Prognosis Estimates by 4 Palliative Care Teams: A prospective cohort study. BMC Palliative Care 2002 1:21', 'Good Medical Practice: General Medical Council 2002' and 'Witholding withdrawing life, prolonging treatments: Good Practice and decision making. General Medical Council 2002'. Associated with CPS000430.
Refers to: 'the statement of Dr Jane Barton (dated April 2005), 'Job Description for Clinical Assistant Post to the Geriatric Division in Gosport' (dated February 2005), 'Statement of Dr Jane Barton' (dated February 2005), 'Report regarding deceased patient' Dr D Black 2005', Gosport Hospital, Mulberry Ward, Dr Lord, CHI report, Dryad, Daedalus, NHS, Portsmouth and South East Hampshire Health Authority and FCE's. Associated with CPS000430.
Refers to: Haslar Hospital, Gosport War Memorial Hospital, General Medical Council, Medicine, David Andrew Black (Dean Director of Postgraduate Medical and Dental Education Kent Surrey and Sussex Deanery), Operation Rochester, Hampshire Constabulary, Haslar Notes, Microfilm notes, Dr Lord, Dr Barton and Dr Tandy. Associated with CPS000477.
Refers to: Dr Jane Barton, Elsie Devine, Hampshire Constabulary, a report regarding Elsie Devine by Dr D Black (dated 2004, exhibit BJC/16), Job Description for Clinical Assistant Post to the Geriatric Division in Gosport, the statement of Dr Jane Barton re Elsie Devine, Medicine, CHI report, Dryad Ward and Daedalus Ward. [Note - 'Appendix 1' and 'Appendix 2' are blank] Associated with CPS000526.
Refers to: Detective Sergeant (Hampshire Constabulary), Mrs Devine's medical records, statement of Dr Judith Stevens (Consultant Nephrologist, Portsmouth Hospitals National Health Service Trust) (number S237), statement of Dr Tanya Cranfield (Consultant Haematologist, Queen Alexandra Hospital) (number S254), statement of Dr Jane Barton (General Practitioner, Forton Medical Centre), Dr Logan (Consultant Physician in Geriatrics), Dr Ravindrane (Specialist Registrar to Dr Logan), Dr P Smith, Dr Taylor (Clinical Assistant in Old Age Psychiatry), Dr Jayawardena (Locum Consultant Physician in Geriatrics), Gosport War Memorial Hospital, Dryad Ward, Dr Reid, Dr Lusznat and CV of Dr Dudley. Associated with CPS000526.
Full title of letter: 'Confidential medical report regarding medical management of patients at Gosport War Memorial Hospital'. Refers to: Gosport War Memorial Hospital, medicines, British National Formulary, Mr Arthur Cunningham, Dr Banks, Dr Lord (Consultant Geriatrician), Dolphin Day Hospital, Dryad Ward, Miss Alice Wilkie, Philip Ward, Daedalus ward, transfer to Gosport War Memorial Hospital (dated 6 August), Dr Peters, Dr Barton, Mr Robert Wilson, Dickens Ward, admission to Accident and Emergency (dated 22 September), Dr Luznat [Lusznat?] (Consultant Psychogeriatrician), transfer to Dryad ward (Gosport War Memorial Hospital) (dated 14 October), Dr Knapman, Mrs Eva Page, admission to Victory Ward (dated 6 February 1998), transfer to Charles Ward (dated 19 February 1998) and transfer to Dryad Ward (dated 27 February 1998). Associated with: CPS000546, CPS000870 and CPS001000.
Includes cover page reading: 'Report by Dr Mundy'. Correspondence re 'Confidential Medical Report Regarding Medical Management of Patients at Gosport War Memorial Hospital'. Subheadings: 'Use of Opioid Analgesics', 'Summary', 'Case Note Reviews', 'Arthur Cunningham', 'Comments', 'Alice Wilkie', 'Comments', 'Robert Wilson', 'Comments', 'Eva Page', 'Comments' and 'Conclusions'. Refers to: four patients, Gosport War Memorial Hospital, '13 years experience as a Consultant Geriatrician', local hospice, medicines, British National Formulary, Second World War, 'Mr Cunningham had a one month admission under the care of Dr Banks for depression in July and August 1998', Dr Lord (Consultant Geriatrician), Dolphin Day Hospital, Dryad Ward (Gosport War Memorial Hospital), Dr Barton, syringe driver, Philip Ward, Daedalus ward, Dr Peters, Robert Wilson admitted via Accident and Emergency (22 September), Dickens Ward, Dr Luznat (Consultant Psychogeriatrician), Dr Knapman, Victory Ward, Charles Ward and an x-ray. Associated with: CPS001397.
Refers to: Professor G A Ford is also Professor of Pharmacology of Old Age (University of Newcastle upon Tyne). Report written for Hampshire Constabulary. Contents: 'Introduction and remit of the report', 'Report on Gladys Mabel Richards', 'Report on Arthur ""Brian"" Cunningham', 'Report on Alice Wilkie', 'Report on Robert Wilson', 'Report on Eva Page', 'Opinion on clinical management at Gosport War Memorial Hospital', 'Appendix 1 - Pharmacology of opiate and sedative drugs' and 'Apprendix 2 - British National Formulary guidelines on prescribing in palliative care and prescribing in the elderly'. Refers to: Professor Ford's experience and training, Detective Superintendent John James (Hampshire Constabulary), Gosport War Hospital, Hampshire Constabulary, 'Comments on the recorded causes of death', correspondence from DS J James (dated 15 August 2001), 'Terms of Reference document', hospital medial records of Gladys Richards, Brian Cunningham, Alice Wilkie, Robert Wilson and Eva Page, witness statements of Leslie France [Frances?] Lack and Gillian MacKenzie, report of Professor Brian Livesley, transcripts of police interviews with Gosport War Memorial staff (Dr Barton, Mr Beed, Ms Couchman and Ms Joice), transcripts of police interviews with Royal Hospital Haslar staff (Dr Reid and Flt Lt Edmondson), transcripts of interviews with patient transfer staff (Mr Warren and Mr Tanner), transcripts of police interviews with or statements from medical and nursing staff (Dr Lord, LM Baldacchino, M Berry, JM Brewer, J Cook, J Dalton, W Edgar, A Fletcher, J Florio and A Funnell), Accident and Emergency Department, Haslar Hospital, Gladys Richards admitted to Haslar Hospital (dated 29 July 1998), Surgeon Commander Malcolm Pott (Consultant orthopaedic surgeon), hemiarthroplasty (dated 30 July 1998), Dr Reid (Consultant Physician in Geriatrics), correspondence from Dr Reid (dated 5 August 1998), medicines, Dr Coales, 'transfer letter' from Sergeant Curran (staff nurse) to the Sister in Charge (dated 10 August 1998), Daedalus ward, Dr Barton [various spellings], Barthel score (2), Dr Brigg, Cdr Spalding, Dr Hamlin (House Officer), bronchopneumonia as cause of death, medicines, Dr Lord, Queen Alexandra [various spellings] Hospital, DC Colvin, DC McNally, Surgeon Commander Scott (Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon), Dr Reid (Consultant Geriatrician), Staff Nurse Brewer, correspondence from Dr Bell (Clinical Assistant) (dated 2 December 1994) re Arthur Cunningham, Merlin Park Rest Home, Dr Banks (Consultant in Old Age Psychiatry), Mulberry A Ward, Thalassa Nursing Home, Dolphin Day Hospital, Dr Lord, staff nurse Tubbritt, Dryad Ward [various spellings], Mr Barton, Addenbrooke Rest Home, Philip Ward (Queen Alexandra Hospital), Alice Wilkie's Mental Test Score (0/10), Alice Wilkie's Barthel score (1/20), Dr Peters, staff nurse Sylvia Roberts, Dr Lusznat (Consultant in Old Age Psychiatry), Robert Wilson's Barthel score (5/20), Dr Knapman, Dr Harris, Dr Shain, Charles Ward, Mrs Page transferred to Dryad ward (27 February 1998), Dr Laing, Barthel index for Mrs Eva Page (0/20 and 2/20), General Medical Council, National Health Service, United Kingdom Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting and British National Formulary. Associated with CPS001397. [Note - Appendix 2' - 'BNF Prescribing in palliative care' is blank] Associated with: CPS001397.
Professor G A Ford is also Professor of Pharmacology of Old Age (University of Newcastle upon Tyne). Includes cover page. Report written for Hampshire Constabulary. Contents: 'Introduction and remit of the report', 'Report on Gladys Mabel Richards', 'Report on Arthur ""Brian"" Cunningham', 'Report on Alice Wilkie', 'Report on Robert Wilson', 'Report on Eva Page', 'Opinion on clinical management at Gosport War Memorial Hospital', 'Appendix 1 - Pharmacology of opiate and sedative drugs' and 'Apprendix 2 - British National Formulary guidelines on prescribing in palliative care and prescribing in the elderly'. Refers to: Professor Ford's experience and training, Detective Superintendent John James (Hampshire Constabulary), Gosport War Hospital, Hampshire Constabulary, 'Comments on the recorded causes of death', correspondence from DS J James (dated 15 August 2001), 'Terms of Reference document', hospital medial records of Gladys Richards, Brian Cunningham, Alice Wilkie, Robert Wilson and Eva Page, witness statements of Leslie France [Frances?] Lack and Gillian MacKenzie, report of Professor Brian Livesley, transcripts of police interviews with Gosport War Memorial staff (Dr Barton, Mr Beed, Ms Couchman and Ms Joice), transcripts of police interviews with Royal Hospital Haslar staff (Dr Reid and Flt Lt Edmondson), transcripts of interviews with patient transfer staff (Mr Warren and Mr Tanner), transcripts of police interviews with or statements from medical and nursing staff (Dr Lord, LM Baldacchino, M Berry, JM Brewer, J Cook, J Dalton, W Edgar, A Fletcher, J Florio and A Funnell), Accident and Emergency Department, Haslar Hospital, Gladys Richards admitted to Haslar Hospital (dated 29 July 1998), Surgeon Commander Malcolm Pott (Consultant orthopaedic surgeon), hemiarthroplasty (dated 30 July 1998), Dr Reid (Consultant Physician in Geriatrics), correspondence from Dr Reid (dated 5 August 1998), medicines, Dr Coales, 'transfer letter' from Sergeant Curran (staff nurse) to the Sister in Charge (dated 10 August 1998), Daedalus ward, Dr Barton [various spellings], Barthel score (2), Dr Brigg, Cdr Spalding, Dr Hamlin (House Officer), bronchopneumonia as cause of death, medicines, Dr Lord, Queen Alexandra [various spellings] Hospital, DC Colvin, DC McNally, Surgeon Commander Scott (Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon), Dr Reid (Consultant Geriatrician), Staff Nurse Brewer, correspondence from Dr Bell (Clinical Assistant) (dated 2 December 1994) re Arthur Cunningham, Merlin Park Rest Home, Dr Banks (Consultant in Old Age Psychiatry), Mulberry A Ward, Thalassa Nursing Home, Dolphin Day Hospital, Dr Lord, staff nurse Tubbritt, Dryad Ward [various spellings], Mr Barton, Addenbrooke Rest Home, Philip Ward (Queen Alexandra Hospital), Alice Wilkie's Mental Test Score (0/10), Alice Wilkie's Barthel score (1/20), Dr Peters, staff nurse Sylvia Roberts, Dr Lusznat (Consultant in Old Age Psychiatry), Robert Wilson's Barthel score (5/20), Dr Knapman, Dr Harris, Dr Shain, Charles Ward, Mrs Page transferred to Dryad ward (27 February 1998), Dr Laing, Barthel index for Mrs Eva Page (0/20 and 2/20), General Medical Council, National Health Service, United Kingdom Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting and British National Formulary. Associated with CPS001397. [Note - Appendix 2' - 'BNF Prescribing in palliative care' is blank] Associated with: CPS001397 and CPS001562.
Refers to: Gosport War Memorial Hospital, medicines, Curriculum Vitae of David Andrew Black, medical records relating to Arthur Cunningham, Operation Rochester Briefing Document Criminal Investigation Summary, Commission for Health Improvement Report (July 2002), Palliative Care Handbook Guidelines on Clinical Management (1995), Wessex Protocols, Waterlow score, Barthel, Merlin Park, Dr Scott Brown (psychiatrist), Dr Lord, Mulberry Ward, Folstein Mini Mental State Examination, Thalassa Nursing Home, Dr Brook, cause of death: 1 - Bronchopneumonia, 2 - Parkinson's Disease, Sacral Ulcer, Solent Cliff Nursing Home, Merlin Park Residential Home, Alverstoke Nursing Home, Barthel, CPN, Dr Barton and Brocklehurst's Text Book of Geriatric Medicine (2003). Associated with: CPS001734, CPS001793, CPS001794 and CPS001799.
Refers to:Gosport War Memorial Hospital, Good Medical practice (GMC, 2001), medicines, sub-optimal drug management, Curriculum Vitae of David Andrew Black, medical records relating to patient, Operation Rochester Briefing Document Criminal Investigation Summary, Hampshire Constabulary Operation Rochester Guidance for Medical Experts, Commission for Health Improvement Investigation Report on Portsmouth Health Care NHS Trust at Gosport War Memorial Hospital (July 2002), Palliative Care Handbook Guidelines on Clinical Management (1995), Wessex Protocols, Dr Banks, Dr Lord (Consultant Geriatrician), Dryad Ward, Dr Barton, Dr Briggs, Staff Nurse Martin, British National Formulary, syringe driver, GP, ECT, 'TLC' and Brocklehurst Text Book of Geriatric Medicine (2003). Associated with: CPS001734, CPS001806 and CPS001811.